Our Story Specialties Menu Reviews Find Us Call to Order
Fresh Mexican dishes on a rustic wooden table
Cicero's Favorite Mexican Grill

Real Mexican Food
That Actually Tastes
Like Home

Every dish at Toucan Annie's is built on recipes we've perfected over years — made from scratch, cooked with intention, and served with the warmth of a family that takes pride in what they do.

Call to Order See the Menu
Scroll
Chef preparing fresh tortillas by hand
Colorful Mexican food spread on a plate

Our Story

We Don't Cut Corners.
We Make Them From Scratch.

Toucan Annie's wasn't built on shortcuts. It was built on the belief that the best Mexican food starts with the simplest things done right — hand-rolled tortillas, slow-braised meats, salsas made fresh every morning, and flavors that remind you of someone's abuela's kitchen.

Located right here in Cicero, we've been serving our neighbors real, honest Mexican food for years. No frozen shortcuts. No pre-made sauces. Just real ingredients, real technique, and a whole lot of heart.

100%
Made from Scratch
Fresh
Daily Ingredients
Local
Cicero Favorite

What Sets Us Apart

Not Just Another Mexican Restaurant

There's a difference between food that fills you up and food that makes you come back. Here's what makes Toucan Annie's different.

Hand-Made Daily

Every tortilla, every taco shell, every quesadilla base is made fresh in our kitchen each morning. You can taste the difference — it's the difference between real food and everything else.

Authentic Recipes

Our recipes come straight from traditional Mexican kitchens — not a menu committee. We slow-braise, we char, we build layers of flavor the way they've been done for generations.

Made with Care

This isn't a chain. It's a neighborhood restaurant where the people who cook your food know your name and care about how it tastes. That personal touch changes everything.

What People Say

Loved by Our Neighbors

The best reviews aren't written by us — they're shared by the people who keep coming back.

I've been coming here for years and it never disappoints. The birria tacos are the real deal — nothing else in Cicero comes close. My whole family eats here every weekend.

M
Maria G.
Local Customer

You can tell everything is made from scratch. The tortillas are soft and warm, the salsas have real flavor, and the portions are generous. This is what Mexican food should taste like.

J
James T.
Local Customer

Finally, a place that takes Mexican food seriously without making it complicated. The mole is incredible, the staff is friendly, and it feels like eating at a friend's house.

S
Sandra L.
Local Customer

Ready to Eat?

Your Table Is Waiting

Whether you're dining in, grabbing takeout, or planning something special, we're ready when you are. Call us to place your order or stop by — we save you a seat.

(317) 606-8141 Get Directions
10 W Jackson St, Cicero, IN 46034
Open 7 Days a Week

Find Us

Come Say Hello

We're Right in the Heart of Cicero

Address 10 W Jackson St, Cicero, IN 46034
Phone (317) 606-8141
Hours Mon–Thu: 11am–9pm · Fri–Sat: 11am–11pm · Sun: 12pm–8pm
Is this your business?This is my business